Mendelssohn: Midsummer Night's Dream / Judd, New Zealand Symphony Orchestra

Mendelssohn / Wollerman / New Zealand So / Judd Release Date: 07/27/2010

Label: Naxos Catalog #: 8570794 Spars Code: DDD

Composer: Felix Mendelssohn Performer: Gunnar Cauthery , David Timson , Tom Mison , Jenny Wollerman ... Conductor: James Judd Orchestra/Ensemble: New Zealand Symphony Orchestra , Nota Bene Choir , Varsity Voices Number of Discs: 1

Works on Recording
Notes and Reviews

MENDELSSOHN A Midsummer Night’s Dream: Complete Incidental Music • James Judd, cond; Tom Mison, Adrian Grove, Emily Raymond, Anne-Marie Piazza, Gunnar Cauthery, Peter Kenny, David Timson (nar); Jenny Wollerman, Pepe Becker (sop); Varsity Voices; Nota Bene; New Zealand SO • NAXOS 8.570794 (76:44)

At the age of only 17, Mendelssohn produced the Overture to A Midsummer Night’s Dream , op. 21. As amazing as this may be, it is Read more equally impressive that when he wrote the rest of the incidental music some decade-and-a-half later, he was able to recapture the spirit of his younger self so vividly, so exactly. Because this music is so often performed as a concert piece, though, we sometimes forget that it is indeed incidental music, written to accompany the spoken word. While there are ample recordings of just the music alone, there are fewer performances of the entire melodrama, and while many of these performances choose to use a single narrator to enact all of the roles (for example, a very fine performance by Seiji Ozawa and the Boston Symphony Orchestra with Dame Judi Dench narrating, on Deutsche Grammophon 439897), the one here has a handful of actors who take on anywhere from two to four roles each. There is something highly convincing about this approach, perhaps because it is performed in the manner that Mendelssohn intended it to be. And though the acting at first seemed to me overdramatic in certain instances, upon repeated listenings the comical aspects, especially, became more apparent. Musically speaking, there is a wonderful sense of youthful energy and sprightliness. James Judd doesn’t overindulge himself; rather he seems to let the music just be. The lighter textures that he keeps help delineate many of the interesting inner voices, and allow splashes of instrumental color that are inherent in Mendelssohn’s orchestration to pop out. All in all, I found myself listening over and over with newfound enthusiasm, and though I still would not be without my other favorite performances (the Ozawa previously mentioned, and Philippe Herreweghe’s stunning account on Harmonia Mundi), the performance here goes to the top of my list of those that include the text. The sound on the disc is perfectly suited to the lighter sounds of this music, only becoming more reverberant when the speakers enter. If one wanted only one recording of the piece, or wanted to add another performance to one’s collection, this is a prime candidate for either. Once again, Naxos produces a winner.

FANFARE: Scott Noriega
Read less

1. Midsummer Night's Dream, Op. 61

Composer: Felix Mendelssohn Performer: Gunnar Cauthery (Narrator) , David Timson (Narrator) , Tom Mison (Narrator) , Jenny Wollerman (Soprano) , Pepe Becker (Soprano) , Adrian Grove (Narrator) , Emily Raymond (Narrator) , Peter Kenny (Narrator) Conductor: James Judd Orchestra/Ensemble: New Zealand Symphony Orchestra , Nota Bene Choir , Varsity Voices

Period: Romantic Written: 1842 Germany

Mendelssohn: Midsummer Night's Dream / Judd, New Zealand Symphony Orchestra

Add To Playlist

Success